Sadly for all its fans, it is still true
that the Tennessee Volunteers have not yet beaten the Georgia Bulldogs, this year's Southeastern Conference champions,
in Knoxville in this century. The last UT victory in the series was in
1999. There was no championship again for Tennessee for the seventh
straight year. Head Coach Phillip Fulmer's career appears to have
peaked with the national championship and back-to-back SEC
championships in 1997 and 1998. It has been all downhill ever since
then.
The
Vols appeared lackluster, undisciplined, unprepared, and generally
lacking in intensity, enthusiasm, and mental toughness. All of these
can be traced back to poor coaching and a lack of leadership. Penalties
were far too common on both sides of the ball, but especially on
offense. Perhaps this was a carryover effect from the off-field problems
that plagued the team this summer, as there was no question that
this might have been the most talented bunch Fulmer has ever had at UT.
Most
UT faithful were all for Fulmer replacing Johnny Majors, despite the
circumstances under which it occurred. However, Majors left a team that
was loaded with talent. He had finally gotten UT back to national
prominence. While Fulmer is a great recruiter for sure, Majors was also
good at it, too, with Fulmer's & others' help.
Majors had
a revolving door of assistants because he was very demanding and very
hard on them. However, he hired the best & the brightest. He held
them accountable for the positions they coached on the team. Many of
them have benefited from that and gone on to be head coaches and
coordinators in the NFL.
Fulmer just hasn't kept the coaching
talent level up on a par with the player talent level. That is the
reason the Vols haven't won any championships since 1998 are unlikely
otherwise to do so again during his tenure. Until and if he jettisons
the dead weight on his staff and brings in brighter, fresher minds, UT
will continue to be adrift despite ample athletic talent.
Tennessee
hasn't won a big game at home in ages. They simply haven't protected
their home turf. This wears on the home crowd. They had tons of
empty seats for the last three home games against South Carolina,
Memphis, and Vanderbilt. They missed out on a bowl altogether and
turned in a losing season, both firsts in Fulmer's career as head coach.
In both the Florida and Georgia games, Tennessee got beat in the kicking game.
Georgia had better punting, better coverage, better returns, and
everything about their special teams were better than the Vols were.
Credit UT’s defense for hanging in there, but their other hallmark down
thru the ages has been the kicking game. They simply must get someone
else on their staff that knows how to coach special teams. General
Neyland must be spinning in his grave.
This year marked three wins in a
row for Georgia at Neyland Stadium for first time in the entire history
of the series, dating back to 1899. That is the sad commentary for those the donors and alumni who pump money into the
Big Orange program and must be counted upon to fund the massive stadium
improvements that Athletics Director Mike Hamilton has in mind for the
next several years.
None of UT’s
receivers ever got open enough to catch the ball, nor did they get open
enough to do anything with it when they do catch it. That is coaching,
pure & simple, teaching them how to properly run routes and get
open. The Vols didn't have anyone open on slants, curls, hooks, or in
the flat all year to speak of.
UT didn't have to run either
Brent Schaeffer or James Banks off the campus. Schaeffer's offenses
were no worse than some of the others on the team. They could have
worked with him and gotten him tutored and eligible with the required
number of hours this past summer. Banks begged to come back. He should
have been given at one last chance. Both may have learned their
lessons.
On top of that, Schaeffer may come back to bite UT
running Urban Meyer's option offense at Florida soon. The lack of the
availability of the talents of both these guys are a big loss to the
team, but the All-America wideouts the Vols have that aren’t being
coached properly is a mystery. Many of them will play in the NFL but
are underachieving due to poor coaching in college. Also inexplicable
is the lack of utilization of the UT tight end, who would provide a
mismatch in every secondary they have faced.
The home crowd was
into the Georgia game from the get-go. No way the home fans
could be blamed for that loss. They were loud & proud. The team and
most especially the coaches simply let them down. The crowd got back
into and behind them in the second half comeback, too.
In their two biggest SEC East games, Florida and Georgia,
the Vol offense was totally shut down. UT’s schemes were far too
predictable. Their formations were dead giveaways to everyone now. They
desperately need new blood in the Tennessee offense.
Tennessee didn't get a decent rush on a punter all season. On top of that,
they rarely fielded punts well. They got pinned deep several times in the
Georgia game. Precious field position was lost by soft special teams
play. That alone could very well have cost UT the game.
Fulmer
is at a similar crossroads to Tommy Tuberville when he pulled the
trigger, fired a lot of his staff, including both coordinators, and
brought it fresh coaching talent. If Fulmer survives, he simply must do
the same. This should have been done years ago. He should have been
replacing at least a couple of his staff already at a minimum. Now it
will require wholesale changes.
The Vols slid to 5-6 from being #2 in the nation. They were
the biggest bust of 2005. They lost to inept Alabama and couldn't even make
the season respectable in the SEC. Beating
b Notre Dame became an impossible dream after the
Georgia performance.
That
made the South Carolina game at home a dangerous
one, and UT became the only quality team that Steve Spurrier, the Ole
Ball Coach, beat in his first year as the head man in Columbia. The
Gamecocks were sky-high coming into Neyland to face a
wounded and demoralized Volunteer team. Tommy West’s
Memphis squad could have beaten the Vols if they had played DeAngelo
Williams, and a rejuvenated Vanderbilt beat them for the first time in
22 years.
Since Majors was replaced, special
teams have been an afterthought at UT, instead of the primary focus the
kicking game should be according the General Neyland's maxims. Majors
was a triple-threat single wing tailback when he played for Bowden
Wyatt, the General’s handpicked successor, in the 1950's. He ran,
passed, and was the punter, too. We haven't had anyone holding our
kicking game accountable since he was fired.
The head coach is
responsible for our abysmal special teams play. We simply must have
Phillip get personally involved in that area and find someone else to
be in charge of it. Steve Caldwell has been relieved of those duties. The kickers, kick
returners, and kick coverers are not being developed.
Take a
look at what Mack Brown has done to rebuild the Texas program. When he
took over, the "other" UT was at a low ebb. He is considered a snake
oil salesman by some, but he is obviously a good recruiter, talked his
team into a BCS Rose Bowl berth last season, won the Big 12 Championship handily, is playing for the National Championship and he has surrounded himself
with a better staff than Fulmer has.
All in all, at least half the staff should be
replaced, and not necessarily on just the offensive side of the ball.
If Fulmer is bold enough to do that after turning in one of the worst
flops of the year in 2005 for someone making over $2 million annually,
he will see vast improvement of this team over night next spring.
Otherwise, he will most likely never win another SEC championship the
rest of whatever career he has left at UT.
The bottom line is
that Tennessee is a big-time program with a huge budget, top talent,
plenty of donors who pour large amounts of cash into it, and facilities
to rival anyone. The fans deserve a far better product on the field
than they are getting. They consistently recruit talent that is the
best or nearly the best in the nation. That talent deserves the best
and brightest coaching minds to develop it, but the coaching they
receive is no better than average at best. Until and if Fulmer realizes
that, busts like last Saturday will continue to happen with regular
frequency year after year. How long will that continue to be tolerated?
Sounds like they could use a guy like Mike Price (former WSU Cougar coach). He was a national joke a couple of years ago for a piece done by S.I. that was proven to be misguided, but you cannot argue his coaching intelligence. I didn't even know UTEP had a football program until he made them respectable.
Boy, you guys are in trouble in the years to come in the SEC. Urban Meyer will have UF rolling big-time, ol' Visor Boy in South Carolina will have that ####-n-Fire offense humming, and Mark Richt will continue to keep winning at UGA. Fulmer is up to his elbows in deep, hot water to get Tennessee back up and running again. Bringing Cutcliffe back was a step in the right direction though. All in all, it will be a steep, steep climb back to the top of the SEC for the Vols.
UT football is just like some other big time college sports programs....Spoiled rotten fans, who panic as parity among the teams becomes more and more of a reality.
John Mark Hancock is a 7th-generatio n East Tennessean, lifelong Knoxvillian & Holston Hills resident, & a 3-time graduate of The University of Tennessee, having earned the B.S., M.B.A., & J.D. degrees. Former attorney, realtor, & professional sports agent for players and coaches. Now an entrepreneur, investor, lobbyist, executive, management, real estate, & investment consultant to several businesses regionally, & free-lance journalist & columnist who is published nationally. Active in the Knoxville Quarterback Club, Big Orange Tipoff Club, U.T. National Alumni Association, President's Club, & Volunteer Athletic Scholarship Fund. Writes opinion commentary that is syndicated & distributed to other media, including sports articles, human interest stories, & political editorials. Please E-Mail him at JMH@ICX.NET